Fri 23 Nov 2007
McLaren & Spying : Round Two
Posted by Craig under Formula 1 with the tags f1 • McLaren • Renault • spyingSo McLaren are now accusing Renault of spying on them in much the same way that McLaren were accused of spying on Ferrari.
The accusations were first raised at the McLaren -v- Ferrari hearing which to me made it look like McLaren were simply trying the “but they have done it as well” tactic more often seen in primary school classrooms, so I didn’t pay them much heed.
Now various documents have been leaked which seem to point to there being more evidence and indeed a much more serious breach of the rules in this case than in the McLaren case - if the evidence really does stack up that is.
Of course we need to wait and see what comes of it all, but there is one thing that sticks in my head - if you are going to cheat and effectively copy someone else’s work then you should aim to copy the person or team who are best.
So that Renault have gone after McLaren shouldn’t come as a surprise as they are usually up near the front of the grid - that Renault should use that information and be totally off the pace for most of the season is unforgivable in my eyes.
Only cheat if you use the information to make you better, not worse! How bad would they have been if they hadn’t used this information?
November 23rd, 2007 at 5:22 pm
[...] is that he will head back to Renault, but they have a huge black cloud hanging over them with the latest allegations of spying yet to be sorted out. Whether they will even be racing next season, or if they are whether they [...]
November 24th, 2007 at 4:23 pm
Isn’t it more a case of use what you get? Had Renault lured a Ferrari employee to work with them, no doubt they would have used whatever he brought with him too. Although I admit they might not have been too keen to use anything coming with an ex-Toro Rosso employee…
November 24th, 2007 at 10:51 pm
I agree, but as Adrian Newey says he reckons it’s fair game to use the things that are in the heads of the people you employ - but not the stuff they download from their old employer specifically to take to a new one.
Still doesn’t explain why Renault were so rubbish even with McLaren’s “secrets”!