Tue 14 Oct 2008
Fuji coverage shows TV must improve
Posted by Craig under Formula 1 with the tags China • F1:2008 • Felipe Massa • FIA • Formula 1 • Lewis Hamilton • StewardsTV coverage of F1 at the moment is much better than it has ever been in my opinion, but it still needs improvement.
In the past we were at the mercy of local directors at each GP who invariably concentrated on the drivers from their particular country. While this is somewhat understandable, it was mightily frustrating if there was more interesting action happening elsewhere on track.
Now, each broadcaster is provided with a common feed from Bernie’s FOM which in my view at least means we usually get to see what we should be seeing although invariably we do miss the odd accident or whatever.
The frustrating thing now however is that we all know the race is covered by dozens of cameras yet during the race we are normally only ever treated to replays from the view we saw in the first place. Often this is of little use in helping to settle any arguments on who was at fault in an accident or whether a penalty was deserved, with last week’s Japanese GP being a case in point.
All cars have cameras fitted to them so it should be possible to see an incident from literally any driver’s point of view - and I’m sure this is one of the options the stewards view when dishing out penalties yet we rarely see these on TV.
Take the start at Fuji for example, watching this onboard footage from Massa and the overhead shot in slow motion shows things in another light for me :
Firstly, I didn’t realise just how close Lewis Hamilton came to taking out his teammate as he switched to the inside of Kimi. It also shows he actually came back onto track just in the lead but had less momentum than Kubica and Alonso which ultimately allowed them to pass him.
Then later in the lap he again runs wide, something never mentioned on TV as far as I’m aware, which dropped him well down the order and was no doubt the confirmation the team needed that his tyres were shot and he would have to pit for a new set.
Now, obviously we can’t see every shot as it happens live - nor can we expect the director to always choose the best camera angle for every incident given just how fast these things occur but surely it can’t be that hard to pick and choose different angles for replays?
Even if for some reason it is hard, then these other angles should at least be available for the highlights show which happens hours later.
I’m not blaming ITV here, I know that they can only show the footage which they are given, but FOM really need to get their finger out to improve things - and the switch to the BBC next year seems the perfect opportunity to do it.
October 14th, 2008 at 8:10 am
That footage (which has probably already been taken down by FOM luddites) comes from their premiere feed, which only certain channels get to use. ITV does not, but I think it is available in Germany. Lots of footage from the premiere feed usually ends up on the end-of-season DVD.
It was the same at Fuji last year - the directors didn’t get a good angle on the Vettel/Webber crash. And only premiere viewers saw Alonso’s crash probably - the rest of the world had to wait for the DVD.
Whatever their business model is, keeping your premium content away from people who want to see it and may be persuaded to pay for it is typically short-sighted FOM marketing practices.
October 14th, 2008 at 8:40 am
@Keith Collantine: Still there at the moment, but it’s only a matter of time!
I know it’s been said before, but this is the kind of footage that could easily be available to the premiere channel on the day but then available to all later in the week - ripe for another show on perhaps a Monday night which would look back at any incidents.
Seriously doubt that a show like that will ever see the light of day though!
October 14th, 2008 at 9:39 am
I would not mind if there is paid version of teh F1 races, be it in hi def or with some KangarooTV like interactive features and without advertising…
but hold on, here we already have F1 on paid channel, with ads interrupting even the Q1 right in the middle and with that stupid Steve Slater commentary
great footage by the way , finally I could see what happened to Hamilton there
October 14th, 2008 at 11:53 am
The Japanese Grand Prix is one of only two races (the other being the Brazilian GP) where the race coverage is still directed by a local TV director. Coverage of all other races apart from these two are FOM-controlled. I think they must have had long-term contracts set in stone before the move to having more FOM-directed coverage.
You are absolutely right about the Japanese GP coverage though. Just like last year, it is only after the race we are beginning to see all of the angles we should have been shown during the race. What a travesty.
October 14th, 2008 at 12:33 pm
@Milos: I also would consider the payment option for extra stuff, and this has been spoken about before - but at the moment it seems unlikely to appear in the UK at least.
@doctorvee: I had a feeling Japan may be outwith FOM’s control but thought it had perhaps been brought into the fold by now.
I still think that even if that footage wasn’t available during the race itself, then ITV should be able to show it in the highlights later on. In any event it should be released along with the stewards thoughts and judgement on it…
October 14th, 2008 at 4:02 pm
[...] Fuji coverage shows TV must improve - craigblog.co.ukCraig writes about the dire television coverage of the Japanese Grand Prix [...]
October 14th, 2008 at 9:15 pm
Craig — absolutely. I’ve read somewhere that the FIA is beginning to make good noises about possibly releasing more data, extra footage, new camera angles and suchlike for controversial stewards’ decisions at least. I think we can say that it’s sorely needed!