Tue 14 Oct 2008
Why I think Lewis Hamilton’s punishment is fair
Posted by Craig under Formula 1 with the tags China • F1:2008 • Felipe Massa • FIA • Formula 1 • Lewis Hamilton • StewardsImagine you are sitting at home watching TV, your kids playing outside, when a car comes hurtling past your front gate at 100mph.
You call the police who stop the car further up the road, breathalyse the guy who turns out to be twice over the limit.
What would you want the police to do?
Would you want them to throw the book at the driver in the hope that doing so ensures he is never stupid enough to do the same thing again? Or would you be thankful he didn’t hit anyone and want the police to simply wave him on his merry way?
It’s this second course of action which Lewis Hamilton wanted the stewards to take at Fuji last week after his overambitious out-braking attempt on Kimi Raikkonen at the first corner.
We both got the same penalty but I didn’t hit anyone and he did Lewis Hamilton
His argument is that he didn’t hit anyone therefore he should have been allowed to race on as if nothing had happened. I know there are several supporters of his argument here, but I just don’t see things the same way he does - something I’m quite grateful for to be honest.
What I would agree with perhaps is the notion that they shouldn’t have both been dealt the same penalty, however there’s not a huge number of options open to the stewards so I have some sympathy with them also.
The fact there wasn’t a coming together with other cars - either Lewis and Kimi, or indeed anywhere else further back was for one reason alone, and that was because everyone avoided Lewis and each other. Nothing to do with Lewis at all. It wasn’t as if he braked too late and then took avoiding action - the positioning of his car meant he had no other option but to go straight on. Thinking about the championship for a second (which Lewis obviously wasn’t at the time), it was quite within the realms of possibility that Kimi could have turned in and taken both Lewis and himself out of the race - and I’ve no doubts that the FIA would have laid the blame at the feet of Lewis.
In fact, Hamilton can think himself lucky that Kimi didn’t take the route as he would be really under pressure in China this weekend :
I have the impression that the powers-that-be regard Lewis’s driving in Fuji at Turn 1 as bordering on reckless and that if he had touched another car or caused an accident he would be looking at a 10-place penalty in Shanghai. There’s no soul-searching there; this another open and shut case as far as the rule-makers are concerned. Ed Gorman, The Times
That would really have put his title hopes on the backburner - especially considering had he been out of the race then Massa wouldn’t have run into him and been hit with his own drive-through penalty. In fact there’s a pretty good chance he would have won the race and would now be leading the championship.
It’s all ifs and buts however, what is certain is that Hamilton must listen to what he is saying about bearing the championship in mind and heed his own advice - he needs to win this championship otherwise the pressure on him each subsequent year he isn’t champion will only build and build.
I’ve said before that due to the number of mistakes made this year I don’t think either Massa or Hamilton really deserve to be called a champion, but given it will happen anyway I’m leaning towards Massa deserving it more than Hamilton at the moment.
October 14th, 2008 at 3:15 pm
A ‘faulty analogy alert’ goes off in my head whenever I read a comparison between driving on a race track and driving on the road. Racing drivers push their machinery to the limit and - despite their skills - mistakes are inevitable. Road drivers must always drive well within their capabilities. The two situation are no more analogous than Max Mosley’s memorably tortuous attempt to compare Eddie Irvine’s shunt at Interlagos in 1994 to a driver who changes lanes on the motorway without indicating.
Yes Hamilton made a mistake, but we’ve seen loads of drivers make mistakes this year. The only difference between what he did at Fuji at what Raikkonen did at Monaco was that Hamilton didn’t hit anyone - and Raikkonen didn’t get a penalty.
Furthermore, if we’re going to accept that Hamilton was in the wrong (and I don’t) then Kovalainen must have been as well.
October 14th, 2008 at 3:46 pm
@Keith Collantine: Okay, two people are running down the road and both grab handbags off old women.
One person opens his bag and finds it’s empty and the other opens his to find £500 in cash. Should the first guy not be punished simply because he didn’t end up with a fistful of cash?
Hopefully that analogy doesn’t set off any alarms in your head as that must be really distracting!
Had Hamilton hit Kimi, Heikki run into the pair of them, Massa run into him and so on down the field, would you still think Lewis should have been allowed to simply wander away unpunished?
Personally I do think his driving was out of order going into that first corner - and I would have thought it had Kimi made that move on Lewis if the positions were reversed. In fact had that been the case, we would likely be talking now about whether Kimi deliberately tried to take Lewis out of the race!
I can honestly say I don’t care who wins the title this year (I think DC is too far behind now isn’t he? ;)) so whether it’s a silver or red car in the wrong doesn’t matter to me.
What I think is the worst part in all this is that Lewis could so easily have taken himself and his teammate out of the race without hitting either Ferrari! Heikki seemed to catch him pretty quickly and then hold station just behind, possibly aware that if he overtook Lewis he would have to engineer a way to allow him in front again at a later point.
I do agree with you that Heikki overshot the corner just as much as Lewis - he was probably watching his teammate to judge when to brake and when Lewis didn’t brake then he didn’t either.
The point I was trying to make though was that Lewis was given a penalty for his driving, and the defence he has put forward is that he shouldn’t have been penalised because he didn’t hit anyone - it’s that I don’t agree with.
October 14th, 2008 at 5:02 pm
and now imagine that outcry if Kimi did make the turn as planned and both him and Hamilton went off the race and … no penalty for Kimi hitting but penalty Hamilton getting in the way … and as you say Massa winning the race and leading the title race by now …
October 14th, 2008 at 6:41 pm
@Milos: Yes, imagine that indeed!